The JLP’s Shadow Cabinet Ministers– How Are They Doing?

Jamaican Opposition Leader Andrew Holness named his Shadow Cabinet at a Jamaica Labour Party (JLP) press conference three months ago. Do you remember who they are? Here’s the list again.

Andrew Holness – Opposition Leader – defence, development, operations of the Office of the Prime Minister

Audley Shaw – Finance, Planning, Growth and Economic Development

Delroy Chuck – Justice, National Security, Electoral Matters and Leader of Opposition Business in the House

Arthur Williams – Information, Public Service, Labour and Leader of Opposition Business in the Senate

Kenneth Baugh – Health and Quality of Life

Karl Samuda – Transport, Works and Infrastructure Development

Edmund Bartlett – Tourism and Travel Service Development

J.C. Hutchinson – Agriculture, Mining and Natural Resource Use

Daryl Vaz – ICT and Digital Society Development

Horace Chang – Housing, Water and Environment

Shahine Robinson – Social Security and Poverty Reduction

Gregory Mair – Industry, Commerce and Energy

Olivia ‘Babsy’ Grange – Youth, Sports, Gender Affairs, Entertainment and Culture

Desmond McKenzie – Urban Renewal, Rural Development and Local Government

Senator Christopher Tufton – Foreign Affairs, Foreign Trade and Investment

Marisa Dalrymple-Philibert – Education and Human Resource Development.

In an earlier post, I said we should demand more from the Opposition. The Opposition’s effectiveness hinges on the effectiveness of its Shadow Ministers.

Some spokespersons, like Ed Bartlett and Olivia Grange were given portfolios with which they were very experienced, having shadowed the portfolio before and then having spent four years as the responsible Minister.

Others, like Christopher Tufton and Marisa Dalrymple-Philibert now have to master a new subject. So at this stage, they are not all on equal footing. In addition, it’s reasonable to expect that the JLP would still be re-grouping after their December 29 electoral loss. There will be assessments to be made, reviews and individual and collective soul-searching going on.

That said, since the Opposition Leader promised a vibrant Opposition, who have we seen and heard from so far?

Audley Shaw, Delroy Chuck, Horace Chang, Arthur Williams, Gregory Mair, Ken Baugh, Karl Samuda, Ed Bartlett and Desmond McKenzie are the primary spokespersons who have been visible, along with the Opposition Leader himself. Olivia Grange has so far been heard primarily responding to the government’s position on the Jamaica 50 celebrations.

We’ve heard very little, if anything, on their portfolio areas from Marisa Dalrymple-Philibert, Daryl Vaz, Shahine Robinson, J.C. Hutchinson or Christopher Tufton.

As stated, it’s early days yet, and another three to six months will give us a better picture of who’s taking their portfolio responsibilities seriously. It will be interesting to see if the list of who is speaking out or not changes in the months ahead.

Has anyone impressed you yet, and if so, who?

3 thoughts on “The JLP’s Shadow Cabinet Ministers– How Are They Doing?

  1. petchary

    Audley Shaw has been strangely quiet. Gregory Mair and Delroy Chuck have made some interesting comments and some worthwhile contributions. The only time I have heard Chris Tufton speaking he has been talking about agriculture. Has he said a word on foreign affairs? Daryl, Ed etc have been utterly silent. What are they waiting for?

    1. djmillerja Post author

      Ed hasn’t been silent actually, he has made several statements on tourism, including calling for the Minister to provide info on the Tourism Enhancement Fund. There’s just much less attention on tourism. Tufton on foreign affairs – no, which is par for that portfolio. Spokesmen are rarely heard, but he also speaks on investment.

      1. petchary

        Ah – OK, I missed Ed’s remarks. What puzzles me most of all is that neither the Finance Minister nor his opposite number has said anything much at all in the last 2 or 3 weeks. Don’t we need some insights on the economy, even a little word? Oh, but the Minister is in Washington, right?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s